Tuesday, March 07, 2006

Mental Health Blogging

Dr. Sanity's round-up of the psychosphere is up. Assistant Village Idiot has a post on when Christian and nutritional myths collide that I found quite interesting:

Things like this just make me crazy. A quote from The Maker's Diet, by Jordan S. Rubin.

"History reveals that the healthiest people in the world were generally the most primitive people as well! Our ancestors rarely died from the diet-and lifestyle-related illnesses that kill most modern people before their time, mainly because they ate more healthfully and had more active lifestyles. (p. 32)"

I don't know anything about the value of Rubin's subsequent advise on diet. And I'm not going to find out either, because this is so amazingly stupid that I won't trust a single thing I read from this point forward.

They died young. Their "lifestyle" consisted of brutal labor and frequent malnutrition. Before 1700, life expectancies were in the 30's worldwide. As recently as 1900, the life expectancy in America was 46 -- and that was the highest in the world. Certainly the many deaths in childhood, and the many deaths in childbirth cut down the average, but do the math. A life expectancy of 35 means way less than half are living to age 70.


Yes, it must be nice to rewrite history in a way that makes the primitive lifestyle seem full of life and health. Sorry, but I would rather be alive today eating a Big Mac and frequenting a cardiac surgeon than to have been subjected to the brutal labor and spartan diet plan of my ancestors.

27 Comments:

Blogger windrago said...

umm a tasty b.mac. How I couldn't agree with you Dr!?!!

6:33 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger Dave said...

Bjorn Lomborg's Skeptical Environmentalist addresses the idea that primitive people had it better than we moderns quite well.

6:37 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger Assistant Village Idiot said...

Gee, thanks. Fogel's "Escape From Hunger and Premature Death 1700-2100" is recommended.

Related anecdote: Son #2 worked last summer in the orphanage his younger brothers come from. He is giving a presentation about the experience at his college, for the people who gave him some of the money to go. He wanted to serve them authentic Romanian snacks. We all suggested Fanta, but our other ideas got more and more ridiculous. I eventually suggested the bread spread with pig fat eaten in the peasant villages. Son #4 also laughed, but added "Hey, it kept me alive for a year." Sadly, it's true. The year before his bio father dropped them off at the orphanage, Chris pretty much did have to scrounge for every meal.

7:28 PM, March 07, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

First Richard Cohen, now this. Is there a Carnival of Idiocy on the web yet?

7:51 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger me said...

Thanks for the perspective Dr. Helen. Now if only I could live that idealized lifestyle of our forebearers....waking up with the sun, going for a relaxing jog with my bow and arrow, shooting a convenient rabbit or two, collecting some wild fruit on the way home, and walking the 5 miles home to my palatial cave, with convenient smokehole, where I have healthy roots and such stored along with plentiful animal meat. Those were the days. :)

9:44 PM, March 07, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I once had a classmate who frequently waxed poetic about the idyllic lifestyle of our ancestors and how the evil capitalists and conservatives were leading us down the path towards destruction. Now, I'm usually in a good mood. Known for it, actually. That one day, though, I was in a bad mood. My knee hurt, my foot hurt, and I was cold. I asked her if she would be content to drop out of college, spend all of her time doing housework, cooking, cleaning animals, and caring for the 8+ babies that people used to be forced to have just to ensure one or two surviving past infancy. I was actually a bit rude (for me, this is a big deal) and said, "That's the 'good old days' you're always one about." Some people laughed, others were annoyed, she didn't talk to me again. In retrospect, this was a good thing, lol.

9:59 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger tree hugging sister said...

I only have to think of those days of my youth (Pre-menopause, get my drift?) to squash any ridiculous, romantic longing for bygone eras. All it takes is remembering (wincing at the thought) what excruciating cramps were like beFORE Motrin, the wonder candy, came into my life. And I weep for all the women of similar agonies who have gone before.

Nope. The here and now is dandy, thank you.

10:47 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger Steven said...

"Our ancestors rarely died from the diet-and lifestyle-related illnesses that kill most modern people before their time, mainly because they" -- died long before diet-and-lifestyle-related illnesses could get them.

(Actually, this guy has about a third of a point. Assuming by "primitive" we're talking hunter-gatherers, our primitive ancestors had better health than the agriculturally-based societies managed until the 20th Century. Low population density and a lack of domesticated animals to serve as a disease resevoir meant disease was realtively uncommon. Starvation was rarer because a society dependent on one staple crop is much more vulnerable to a sudden affliction attacking that single food source than a society with multiple calorie sources is to an affliction affecting one of its food sources. And the hunter-gatherer lifestyle, overall, took much less labor than farming. Children under five dropped like flies, women died in childbirth with high regularity, wound infections were very dangerous, and the chance of dying from violent interactions with other people was incredibly high -- but except for the last, the same was true to the same degree in agricultural societies. The only advantage agriculture had was that it was able to support many more people per acre than hunter-gatherers could -- and so the agriculturalists were able to win wars with superior numbers and take over the world.)

11:11 PM, March 07, 2006  
Blogger EvilPundit said...

This touches on an idea I've been kicking about for some time.

That is, when we see headlines about rising causes of death -- the "cancer epidemic" a few years ago, the depression/suicide epidemic in Australia now -- these are actually reflections of a healthier society.

People who in the past would have succumbed to smallpox, tuberculosis or starvation are now evading these traditional killers. But mortality remains at 100%. Therefore, previously obscure causes of death become more and more prominent as traditional nemeses are conquered.

4:13 AM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger jw said...

"History reveals that the healthiest people in the world were generally the most primitive people as well!"

"They died young. Their "lifestyle" consisted of brutal labor and frequent malnutrition."

Both statements are partially true. Obviously both are partially false.

The "most' primitive people? OK, so we're looking at the remaining set of neolithics to get a good idea of the most primitives. The neolithics live an OK life expectancy in that they live a lot longer than poor pre-1950's city dwellers. They do not live any where near as long as moderns.

Brutal labor and frequent malnutition?
True enough for the city dwellers and the serfs -- at least most of the serfs. As far back as we know the free farmers lead a lifestyle roughly equal to the farmers who were most of our ancesters: In other words plenty of food and hard work, but hardly brutal.

This is the thing I spoke of on AVI's blog. The masses had it hard. The rich had things a lot better. Mind you, there were a lot of people who were neither and they had things better than the rich.

5:22 AM, March 08, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anybody ever have a toothache? I have two words for people who wax poetic about past eras. "Modern dentistry."

8:04 AM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger Assistant Village Idiot said...

I frequently agree with jw, so I am reluctant to take him on too hard here. But the point is -- no, not really. There was never a time and place when most people had abundant, or even enough food year-round. If you lived to be 40, you would have gone through at least one, and likely two, periods of serious shortage, resulting in starvation for some. I think most commenters are agreeing with my central point, but not the extremity of my description. I stand by it. It really was that bad.

When food increases in an area, the population grows, not the average caloric intake. That is terribly sad, perhaps, but seems to be how we collectively decide to act. Only the cultural changes since 1700 have reversed that.

9:29 AM, March 08, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Being eaten by leopards may be a lifestyle, but it's hardly a lifestyle choice. As the fossils of some of our earlier ancestors show, we used to be on both sides of the predator-prey interaction.

9:37 AM, March 08, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

There is a lot of foolishness of this sort around. Another similar fad is the marketing of unpasturized milk as "more healthy." When you mention diseases like undulent fever (Brucellosis), they've never even heard of it.

9:55 AM, March 08, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

JW speaks of "at the remaining set of neolithics to get a good idea of the most primitives"

The problem with that reasoning is that remaining neolithics are isolated in reservations, preserves, etc. and beyond the borders of such small territories are huge numbers of people with vaccines and antibiotics, thus shielding them from the diseases spread by human migration. Then there is the action of missionaries, the WHO, and other aid organizations to bring them modern medicine, food in famine, etc. The life expectency and health of remaining neolithics is "subsidized" by efforts of moderns. Even when there's no interaction, because of modern society, an isolated village deep in the Amazon will never face the prospect of a smallpox carrier wandering into their midst.

11:55 AM, March 08, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

People who long for the good old days do have a choice. It is possible to buy some land and live as primitivly as one wishes. (The same is true for communists/socialists. If you think it's so great go start a commune.) By all means, go live as you wish and LEAVE ME ALONE!

12:57 PM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger DADvocate said...

Public health practices (clean drinking water, sewage treatment, vaccination, etc.) have done as much for longivity as medical science according Ivan Illich in "The Medical Nemesis." We don't hear of typhoid, tetanus, polio, cholera, scarlet fever, etc. much any more.

I'm especially glad to having been born in this era as, due to a childhood injury and a congenital intestinal problem, I probably wouldn't have lived to adulthood. As it is I not only survived but played sports, slept in warm beds, and enjoyed excellent health thanks to the medical professions.

2:42 PM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger Steve Skubinna said...

Plus you have enough teeth to masticate a Big Mac, judging from your photo. You likely wouldn't in a prehistoric hunter-gather culture, assuming you had lived as long as you have so far in this one (what did the Flintstones use for defibrillators?).

8:13 PM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger Assistant Village Idiot said...

"What did the Flintstones use for defibrilators?"

Bam-Bam.

8:53 PM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger El Jefe Maximo said...

Several years back, I spent some time in Central Arkansas, and visited a State Park where there was a logging display.

The place was located at the edge of a forest that had once been logged, the bed for the little railroad that ran trees to the mill out ,and supplies in, was still there. The area had last been worked in the 1920's.

Looking at the trees, at the pre-modern saws, axes and equipment, and thinking how much of the work had been performed by raw muscle power, rather than machine, I can still remember how profoundly thankful I was that it wasn't me working in that forest, in those days.

10:04 PM, March 08, 2006  
Blogger pst314 said...

Another of the characteristics of tribal life which these nostalgia-besotted folks forget: War. Wars were frequent and deadly. A far, far larger fraction of primitive populations died from war than did even 20th century Westerners who fought two world wars and suffered genocides.

9:35 PM, March 09, 2006  
Blogger Vicoprofen said...

I think this topic is very different and there should be more pages like this,Your comment has a lot of truth to it, and I'd like to invite you to visit my page:
10/325-
Vicoprofen - Lortab- Tylenol
#3
- Ativan
All Major Medications are available right here at: http://www.crdrx.com

2:45 PM, January 08, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

85cc免費影城 愛情公寓正妹牆川藏第一美女 成人影片 情色交友網 美女視訊 美女視訊 視訊情人高雄網 JP成人影城 383成人影城 aa片免費a片下載 a片線上看aa片免費看 ※a片線上試看※sex520免費影片※ aa片免費看 BT成人論壇 金瓶影片交流區 自拍美女聊天室 aa片免費a片下載 SEX520免費影片 免費a片 日本美女寫真集 sex520aa免費影片 sex520aa免費影片 BT成人網 Hotsee免費視訊交友 百分百貼影片區 SEX520免費影片 免費視訊聊天室 情人視訊高雄網 星光情色討論版 正妹牆 383成人影城 線上85cc免費影城 85cc免費影城 85cc免費影城 85cc免費影城 ※免費視訊聊天室※ ※免費視訊聊天室※ 免費視訊聊天室 85cc免費影片 85cc免費影片 080苗栗人聊天室 080苗栗人聊天室 080中部人聊天室 080中部人聊天室 免費a片下載 免費a片 AA片免費看 aa片免費看 aa片免費看 aa片免費看 aa片免費看 日本av女優影片 av女優 av女優無碼影城 av女優 av女優 百分百成人圖片 百分百成人圖片 視訊情人高雄網 電話交友 影音電話交友 絕色影城 絕色影城 夜未眠成人影城 夜未眠成人影城 色咪咪影片網 色咪咪影片網 色咪咪影片網 色咪咪影片網 色咪咪影片網 免費色咪咪貼影片 免費色咪咪貼影片 色情遊戲 色情遊戲 色情遊戲 色情遊戲 影音視訊交友網 視訊交友網 080視訊聊天室 ※免費視訊聊天室※ ※免費視訊聊天室※ 視訊聊天室 成人影音視訊聊天室 ut影音視訊聊天室 ※免費視訊聊天室※ 視訊ukiss聊天室視訊ukiss聊天室 視訊交友90739 視訊交友90739 情人視訊網 168視訊美女 168視訊美女 168視訊美女 視訊美女館 視訊美女館 免費視訊美女網 小高聊天室 小高聊天室 aio交友聊天室 aio交友聊天室 交友聊天室 交友聊天室 線上a片 線上a片 線上a片 線上a片 線上a片 免費線上a片 免費線上a片 嘟嘟成人網站 成人漫畫 情色文學 嘟嘟成人網 成人貼圖區 情色文學成人小說 微風成人區 情色貼圖區 免費視訊聊天 免費成人圖片區 愛情公寓 愛情公寓聊天室 寄情築園小遊戲 免費aa片線上看 aa片免費看 情色SXE聊天室 SEX情色遊戲 色情A片 免費下載 av女優 俱樂部 情色論壇 辣妹視訊 情色貼圖網 免費色情 聊天室 情人視訊聊天室 免費a片成人影城 免費a片-aa片免費看 0204貼圖區 SEX情色 交友聊天-線上免費 女優天堂 成人交友網 成人情色貼圖區 18禁 -女優王國 080視訊美女聊天室 080視訊聊天室 視訊交友90739 免費a片 aio 視訊交友網 成人影城-免費a片※免費視訊聊天※85cc免費影片日本線上免費a片 免費色咪咪影片免費色咪咪影片aaa片免費看影片aaa片免費看成人影城免費色咪咪影片

1:24 PM, April 05, 2009  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

小魔女免費影城免費看 aa的滿18歲影片sex383線上娛樂場kk777視訊俱樂部aa的滿18歲影片85cc免費影片a片免費看A片-sex520視訊聊天室v6 0plus論壇sex520免費影片avdvd-情色網qq美美色網ut13077視訊聊天A片-無碼援交東京熱一本道aaa免費看影片免費視訊聊天室微風成人免費視訊聊天 ut聊天室av1688影音視訊天堂免費 a 片85cc免費影城亞洲禁果影城微風成人av論壇sex520免費影片JP成人網免費成人視訊aaa影片下載城免費a片 ut交友成人視訊85cc成人影城免費A片aa的滿18歲影片小魔女免費影片85cc免費影片aaa片免費看短片aa影片下載城aaaaa片俱樂部影片aaaaa片俱樂部aa的滿18歲影片小魔女免費影片台灣論壇免費影片後宮0204movie免費影片免費卡通影片線上觀看線上免費a片觀看85cc免費影片免費A片aa影片下載城ut聊天室辣妹視訊UT影音視訊聊天室 日本免費視訊aaaa 片俱樂部aaaa片免費看影片免費視訊78論壇情色偷拍免費A片免費aaaaa片俱樂部影片aa影片下載城色漫畫帝國av俱樂部aaaa彩虹頻道免費影片 杜蕾斯成人免費卡通影片線上觀看85cc免費影片線上觀賞免費線上歐美A片觀看免費a片卡通aaa的滿18歲卡通影片sex520免費影片免費 a 片

4:00 AM, April 14, 2009  
Blogger Unknown said...

外遇外遇外遇外遇外遇外遇外遇外遇外遇 外遇
外遇 外遇外遇 外遇 外遇
外遇 外遇 外遇
外遇


外遇 外遇
外遇
外遇 外遇外遇
外遇

外遇 外遇外遇 外遇 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 ,
外遇 外遇 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇外遇 外遇外遇 外遇 外遇

外遇 外遇

外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇 , 外遇劈腿劈腿劈腿劈腿劈腿劈腿劈腿劈腿喜帖囍帖卡片外遇外遇 外遇 外遇外遇 外遇
外遇 外遇 外遇 外遇剖析 外遇調查 外遇案例 外遇諮詢 偷情 第三者外遇話題 外遇發洩 感情挽回 徵信社 外遇心態 外遇 通姦 通姦罪 外遇徵信社徵信社外遇 外遇 抓姦徵信協會徵信公司 包二奶 徵信社 徵信 徵信社 徵信社 徵信社 徵信社 徵信 徵信 婚姻 婚前徵信 前科 個人資料 外遇 第三者 徵信社 偵探社 抓姦 偵探社 偵探社婚 偵探社 偵探社偵探家事服務家事服務家電維修家事服務家事服務家事服務家事服務家事服務持久持久持久持久持久持久持久離婚網頁設計徵信社徵信社徵信徵信社外遇離婚協議書劈腿持久持久持久持久持久劈腿剖析徵信徵信社外遇外遇外遇外遇徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信徵信社徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信社徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信公會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信公會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信公會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 徵信協會 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿 劈腿

2:02 AM, April 20, 2009  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

視訊做愛視訊美女無碼A片情色影劇kyo成人動漫tt1069同志交友網ut同志交友網微風成人論壇6k聊天室日本 avdvd 介紹免費觀賞UT視訊美女交友..........................

10:26 PM, May 19, 2009  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

情色文學情色小說情色視訊台灣kiss情色文學彩虹性愛巴士情色交友情色論壇聊天室ut情色網麗的情色小遊戲台灣情色網情色遊戲情色小遊戲情色小站情色影片情色貼片金瓶梅影片交流情色漫畫38ga免費a片情色文章情色圖貼天堂情色網情色網站情色自拍情色圖片

10:37 PM, June 07, 2009  

Post a Comment

<< Home