It's About Time
Congress finally acknowleges that family violence strikes men too. What a novel idea.
As Cathy Young points out, we still have a long way to go, but sometimes awareness is the first step to recovery.
Last month, in a little-noticed end-of-the-year action, Congress reauthorized the Violence Against Women Act. The final version includes text that, for the first time, recognizes male victims of domestic violence and sexual assault. This is a step in the right direction of a balanced approach to family violence—but only the first step.
As Cathy Young points out, we still have a long way to go, but sometimes awareness is the first step to recovery.
posted by Helen at 7:31 AM
25 Comments:
when I was growing up, many people brought their teen agers to the local bar on a Sunday afternoon. (I think this method of education about alcohol would still work today, and it is also very educational about alcohol's effects.)
One Sunday I was playing shuffleboard and overheard a guy thing discussion of who was boss in the family.
One truck driver type, (6'6", 250 pounds,) expounded "I keep my wife barefoot and pregnant." Almost immediately there was a tap on his shoulder. He turned, looked down and mumbled, "Oh, hello dear!" His wife had come into the bar just seconds before.
His wife, (under 5' and 100 pounds,) stretched up and using her thumb and finger, took him by the earlobe and marched him out of the bar, (leaving his money, cigarettes, lighter etc.)
Human interactions are often wonderfully complex.
Interesting to see this the day after Colts cornerback Nick Harper played in the game against the Steelers while his wife sat in jail on serious charges stemming from an incident Saturday in which she stabbed him in his knee (I blogged about this earlier this morning).
Daniell Harper, predictably, claims it was an accident, and of course we don't know all the facts yet. Harper himself has a domestic battery case pending against him.
Dr. Helen, you do us all a service when you refer to whole area as "family" rather than "domestic" violence. The latter seems a label too easy to hide behind (and its too associated with women-as-victims only), while the former better captures the reality and the tragedy of this sort of situation. It also implies the presence of others who belong in the equation, as bystanders--that is, any children in the situation.
Family violence is usually a two-way street. Just because a man is as big as a football player, doesn't mean that he might not be meek as a lamb when a five foot two woman comes by. Interpersonal violence is often psychological and depends not necessarily on who has the most physical strength but rather, who has the most willingness to use violence to solve an interpersonal problem--the complexity of human emotion knows no gender boundaries.
Amen!
Thanks for your ongoing posting on this important issue.
It's like I told my wife when asked her to stop hitting me, "playfully" or otherwise (she was consistently not bothering to aim and ending up below the belt):
You hit me and it's cute.
I hit you and I go to jail.
Dave,
You don't get around much--the stats have been out for a while. Start here for a good background of studies that show women to be as physically aggressive as men in relationships.
http://www.csulb.edu/~mfiebert/assault.htm
robosquirrel makes a good point. Watch TV shows and see how many times it's supposed to be funny when a woman hits or slaps a man. I remember on an episode of the old "What Do You Say To a Naked Lady" show an elderly couple were the dupes and the woman must have slapped the man on the shoulder and back 50 times or more. I really wondered how "funny" this would have been if the roles were switched.
Unfortunately, I have nothing more than anecdotal evidence to add to the discussion…
In my youth a young woman, for reasons never fully explained, unloaded a kick in my groin at the local pool. Later she muttered something about just wanting to see what would happen.
Another charming young lady slapped my face and drove my head into a door jam. (She had been provoked—in spite of our familiarity with one another, I had transgressed established boundaries with a salacious remark. Still, a stern rebuke would have been more appropriate).
Later in life I spent time with a woman who had a bit of a reputation for having a bad temper. She was a hundred and ten pounds soaking wet, standing five-foot-three-inches tall. There was nothing but dynamite packed into that frame, and if someone lit that short fuse—look-out. She backed big men down with shear ferocity.
Another New England beauty—tall, lean and wonderful—recounts a story of an altercation with a demure smile. She had a close call on the road with a gentleman driving a Corvette. After a near collision both she and this man pulled over, each angry at the other. She climbed out of her vehicle, ran to the driver’s side of his car and began kicking the door, cursing like a modern sailor only wishes he could curse. The Corvette driving gentleman left abruptly without further engaging the beauty.
One charming conversation with a modern woman ended abruptly when she declared men were the source of all relational discord. I left, shaking my head at the shear idiocy of her declaration.
There are so many more tales to tell… Still, I’m only a male, and women are quite clearly superior in nature to my brutish, unthinking masculinity. Feh.
Dr. Helen,
I apologize if my 1:13 PM post veers a bit off topic—my frustration got the better of me I’m afraid.
As you indicated earlier in the thread, there’s ample evidence of female to male aggression, rendering my anecdotes unnecessary. The point I had hoped to express was simply an affirmation of the declaration you made in this thread: “it’s about time”. It is about time.
Thanks
Jephnol,
I like anecdotes, they bring us more awareness of examples of actual problems and situations that people have. Thanks for sharing yours.
Does anyone have any statistics on the proportion of men needing medical attention (bleeding, broken bones etc) after being attacked by female significant others vs women needing medical attention after being attacked by male significant others?
That might bring some proportion to the issue.
The problem in that case would be reporting, much like rape statistics, which are notoriously unrealiable because victims may be too ashamed/afraid/intimidated/whatever to actually seek treatment.
Sometimes an excerpt says more or says it better than I ever could;
" [...] Feminist created “domestic violence” laws serve as another way to give women an upper hand over men while keeping them dependent on men and the government. Domestic violence laws are not necessary, since there are already well-established laws in place preventing assault and battery. But feminists wanted to give women an advantage in the home over their husbands and boyfriends by teaching them to involve the government in order to win verbal arguments. Domestic violence laws now include “glaring looks” and “financial violence,” whatever that means. Somewhere less than twenty percent of all domestic violence calls even involve an allegation of assault. Domestic violence laws give women an edge over men because men are five to nine times less likely to call the police over a dispute than women are. Police reports and restraining orders play a large role in deciding child custody issues, so the more a woman calls the police, the better chances she has at obtaining custody of any mutual children along with “free” child support.[...] "
By Rachel Alexander August 3 2003, you can read the rest at
http://www.intellectualconservative.com/article2535.html
Rachel Alexander is a former Assistant Attorney General for the State of Arizona.
We have a standing joke on admissions about couples where who gets the restraining order is a product of who got down to the courthouse first.
That said, my estimate is that violence against women is more common, just not as astronomically disproportionate as is popularly supposed.
A couple of years ago, in Men's Health magazine, they published numbers on "domestic" violence in the USA, and guess what?
In more than half the cases, women did admit to the police they were the first to hit the other, and in many cases women also did admit they did it with an object like a cell phone or a shoe, and in the face!
I've never had someone - man or woman - hit me in the face with a hard object like a shoe, but I'd say it must be difficult to not hit back, very difficult...
And in most cases, even when it was the man that called the police complaining his wife was being violent, they still took the man back to the police station!!!
I don't know if those numbers are available on the net, I think I kept that magazine in a box somewhere...
I'll try to find it.
"Interpersonal violence is often psychological," says Dr. Helen. And she's right. As a result, I think no DV stat is accurate enough to put family violence into proportion.
Jephnol, I'm terribly sorry to hear about your experience at the pool. One of my major pet peeves is the lack of honor attributed the male anatomy.
Men have a right, and as humans a natural need, to feel pleased with and grateful for their bodes. But unfortunately, our weaknesses are so often exploited that it makes it hard to feel comfortable in our own skin, so to speak (which I'm sure is why some men will go as far as to call this kind of assault an equivalent to rape).
I think, after reading the comments here, that first some cultural work needs to be done. Men need to be given the message "It's okay to tell people when you've been a victim of violence perpetrated by a woman." I have no idea how to get that out in mainstream US culture. Good luck.
Until that message is accepted, however, doing something about women's violence against their husbands is a non-starter.
" I've long thought that the best indicator for family violence is the 2:1 ratio based on need for medical care. That is two female victims for every one male victim. That ratio has the best science to back it up. "
Sorry but that does not tell you who is abusing who or who started the fight, it only tells you who won the fight or who is stronger, just like when a human gets bitten by a dog,
the fact that the human is the one bleeding and the dog is not, does not tell you what happened.
The fact that the human requires stitches does not prove the human was the victim or that the dog is vicious.
You can not see the days or weeks of teasing and taunting the dog went through before it got to this point, you can only see the bite on the human's hand.
A few punches from a 5'2" and 105 pound woman can not leave much of a mark on a man, but the damage on a woman's face from one single punch from a 6'2" 250 pound man will make a nice front page photo for your local news paper...but it does not tell the story - at all.
I could have gone with the car analogy; in a two car accident, does the fact that the compact car has suffered much more damage than the big SUV proves the SUV's driver is the one who ran the red light?
Here's a question -- how can I help a male friend who is definitely a victim? His girlfriend is totally psycho and beats up on him about once a month, he's had multiple black eyes and broken teeth when she kicked him. He was abused by his mother as a child, this is probably why he stays in this relationship and doesn't fight back ever. He's not a big guy, but she's 5'0 and about 100 pounds, and he could overpower her but he won't. So, what are his friends to do? No one says anything to him about it, but I think by just watching it happen we're enabling it. If the roles were reversed, someone would have said something by now. Is there any kind of men's support group I could refer him to? He definitely would not call the police, and the abuse never happens when any of us are around. Basically we're all hoping his gf will get bored and leave, but I she's been around for about 2 years so I'm afraid its not going to happen -- she probably won't be able to find another guy who will take her abuse very easily. Its really sickening.
Anonymous, it sounds to me like nothing less than professional help is going to work in tha situation.
anonymous:
I don't know the legal statutes in your state regarding domestic abuse. However, I suggest that you talk with your friend and help him to get to a therapist who should be able to point him in the right direction. Make sure he finds a therapist who deals with men's issues or is familiar with battered males.
For what it's worth;
remember when that woman cut off her husband's penis? Bobbit I believe was his name?
Many women journalist were celebrating that act, it was presented in many magazines as a victory for women...
Can you imagine men journalist celebrating the fact that a man cut off his wive's breasts?
No one would publish that - ever.
A couple of years ago some feminists were claiming that on Super Bowl day, violence against women increased a lot.
They backed their claims with a study.
Some tv stations - including ABC - even offered free air time to some women group, so they could inform people of that dangerous day...
It turned out the whole thing was bogus, even the study was bogus.
Feminists in general are very unfair.
Feminists have replaced a tyranny with another.
They should change their name for Hatemenist which is what they really are.
Try this website to get help for abused men: http://www.dahmw.org/pub/
希望大家都會非常非常幸福~
「朵朵小語‧優美的眷戀在這個世界上，最重要的一件事，就是好好愛自己。好好愛自己，你的眼睛才能看見天空的美麗，耳朵才能聽見山水的清音。好好愛自己，你才能體會所有美好的東西，所有的文字與音符才能像清泉一樣注入你的心靈。好好愛自己，你才有愛人的能力，也才有讓別人愛上你的魅力。而愛自己的第一步，就是切斷讓自己覺得黏膩的過去，以無沾無滯的輕快心情，大步走向前去。愛自己的第二步，則是隨時保持孩子般的好奇，願意接受未知的指引；也隨時可以拋卻不再需要的行囊，一路雲淡風輕。親愛的，你是天地之間獨一無二的旅人，在陽光與月光的交替之中瀟灑獨行.................
uthome 視訊聊天室uthome 視訊聊天室546 視訊聊天室546 視訊聊天室免費視訊聊天室免費視訊聊天室club 意難忘視訊交友club 意難忘視訊交友免費 msn 視訊交友 0982視訊聊天室免費 msn 視訊交友 0982qq 視訊交友qq 視訊交友lover99 視訊交友lover99 視訊交友視訊交友聊天室 no8視訊交友聊天室 no8oec 喔伊細辣妹視訊交友oec 喔伊細辣妹視訊交友視訊交友 kugirl視訊ukiss視訊交友 kugirl電話網愛視訊交友
Post a Comment
<< Home